Ingle said he wasn’t aware he had a transgender classmate. Although it wasn’t obvious to some people in the classroom, that student is transgender. It was during that phase of Ingle’s remarks that one student quietly walked out. At one point he veered into his stance on transgender issues. He argued that the male-female wage gap was not fueled by discrimination. He disputed the professor’s right to allow female students to speak first. “Animated, rude, and I guess passionate” is how Bradshaw, who calls herself “center-left” politically, described Ingle’s behavior. Not quite shouting, she said, but the elevated voice of someone seeking attention from 25 feet away.Įxcept the professor was not 25 feet away, Bradshaw said.
![iup professor alison downie iup professor alison downie](https://bloximages.newyork1.vip.townnews.com/indianagazette.com/content/tncms/assets/v3/editorial/5/4d/54d0cea8-3cc9-11e8-a220-63b1a1a7954b/5accc6cb56f15.image.jpg)
One of Ingle’s classmates, Kate Bradshaw, said Ingle’s voice was definitely raised. Ingle described his tone of voice as impassioned, not shouting. To back down in that moment, he said, would have been “kneeling to the stupidity of that sort of structured conversation.” “She asked me to stop talking because I was a man, and I told her that she was in no position to do so,” Ingle said in an interview. He didn’t think it was right that male students should wait, no matter what the professor had said. So Ingle, who is generally outspoken in class, jumped in. The only problem: Alison Downie, the professor, asked female students to share their reaction to the video first. But after the Ted Talk video, he was eager to voice his objections to the transgender minister’s opinions that “mansplaining” is widespread and women “work twice as hard for half as much.” Lake Ingle, a religious-studies major, missed that class. The video served as a contrast to a more-conservative view of Christianity, evangelicalism, which had been highlighted in the previous class. The minister also spoke about the delicate process of gaining some acceptance from her conservative Christian family. Students in the religious-studies class, “Self, Sin, and Salvation,” had just watched a Ted Talk video of a transgender minister who spoke about how she had become more aware of the obstacles faced by women once she outwardly expressed herself as a woman. “I felt I had no choice but to look for help from other people,” he says of his decision to campaign against the professor and the university in the conservative media. of Pennsylvania student, appears on Fox News. YouTube Lake Ingle (right), the Indiana U. “Free speech is under attack in college campuses, it really is.” “Thank you for what you’re doing,” Kirk told him from the stage. Kirk began his speech at the university by calling Lake Ingle “amazing.” At what point does a heated exchange become disrespect? And who gets to decide? It’s a fresh lesson in the power of the conservative media to shape the free-speech debate on campuses, and how that debate can challenge the core academic mission of colleges and universities. What happened in one classroom made a student into a right-wing hero, and turned the professor into a target. Ingle gave interviews, too, to alt-right outlets such as Red Ice TV, a YouTube channel hosted by the “pro-European” white nationalist Henrik Palmgren. “College student kicked out of class for telling professor there are only two genders,” proclaimed Fox News.
![iup professor alison downie iup professor alison downie](http://resources2.news.com.au/images/2011/10/23/1226174/447722-alison-downie.jpg)
![iup professor alison downie iup professor alison downie](https://mediadc.brightspotcdn.com/dims4/default/c713f5d/2147483647/strip/true/crop/2832x1487+0+306/resize/1200x630!/quality/90/?url=http%3A%2F%2Fmediadc-brightspot.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fb1%2F16%2F929c915e475bbe5738c1fe09d69b%2Fiup-wilson.jpg)
His professor said it was his disruptive behavior, not any debate over the number of genders, that was the problem. A senior there, Lake Ingle, told conservative media outlets he had been kicked out of a religious-studies class because he argued that only two genders exist. The rural state university, in a former coal-mining town, had become one of the latest battlegrounds in the nation’s culture wars. Kirk - the head of Turning Point USA, a conservative political-advocacy group - took the stage this spring at Indiana University of Pennsylvania wearing a navy-blue T-shirt that read: “There are only two genders.” He said a professor’s attempt to remove a disruptive student from her class exemplified how “free speech is under attack in college campuses.”Ĭharlie Kirk showed up dressed for the occasion. Chronicle Photograph by Michael Vasquez Charlie Kirk, founder of Turning Point USA, a conservative advocacy group, speaking at Indiana U.